Do Basel capital standards have the force of law in the United States?
Do Basel capital standards have the force of law in the United States?
Explain.
- B. After examining Lithium Bank, examiners conclude that the bank would have
excessive difficulty in turning its assets into cash on short notice and in obtaining
cash quickly from outside sources. Which component of the bank’s CAMELS
rating is this conclusion most likely to affect? Explain.
_________________________
—8-Minute Questions (8-sentence limit)
- C. Titania and Nick have the following exchange:
TITANIA: Oh, c’mon, Nick! Much as I like you, I know you too well to believe
you’re an international banker. You’ve spent your life in this town, and
you work for a local bank.
NICK: But I’m still an international banker.
TITANIA: And I’m Hermione Granger.
NICK: Let me show you. Logs on to his computer. See that?
TITANIA: Numbers. Columns of numbers. And if I look hard enough, I’ll see the
Bank of England, right?
NICK: This is a special set of asset and liability accounts at that “local bank” I
work for: international assets and international liabilities. I’m in charge
of them, and that makes me an international banker.
TITANIA: You’re still a homebody.
What concept from this course best describes the set of accounts to which Nick
refers? Explain.
PAGE 5 OF 10
- D. Customers of Mercury National Bank keep U.S. $100 million in demand deposits at
the bank’s Copenhagen branch. Must the bank maintain reserves against those
deposits? Would it matter whether depositors can also collect their money at the
bank’s main office in San Francisco? Explain.
ESSAY QUESTIONS
ESSAY 1 (60 minutes)
Argon Bank, chartered and headquartered in the Republic of Lutetia, has an FDIC-insured
federal branch in the City of Hesperia, State of Greenbrier. The bank established the
branch and obtained FDIC insurance for it in 1987.
Krypton Bank, chartered and headquartered in the Republic of Promethia, has no branch,
agency, or other office in the United States. During the past five years, three other
Promethian banks with no U.S. offices applied to establish state branches or agencies in
other states. The Federal Reserve Board approved all three applications, without imposing
conditions.
Lutetia and Promethia both permit U.S. banks to enter only by establishing or acquiring a
bank chartered by that country. Greenbrier’s largest bank sought unsuccessfully to
persuade Lutetia to adopt more liberal entry rules.
Radon Bank, chartered and headquartered in the Kingdom of Samarica, has a federal
agency in Hesperia and a federal branch in New York City.
Argon Bank runs advertisements mocking stodgy, inflexible bankers. It gains many new
customers, primarily individuals and small businesses. Local banks take great offense.
Radio talk show hosts warn of a foreign financial takeover. The Greenbrier Legislature
enacts the Foreign Bank Fairness Act of 2013:
No foreign bank may establish any branch, agency, or other banking office in this
state unless the foreign bank’s home country accords United States banks
competitive opportunities equal to those it accords to banks chartered in that
country.
————————
PAGE 6 OF 10
(a) May Radon Bank’s Hesperia agency issue a standby letter of credit, as the laws of
Samarica permit it to do? Explain.
(b) Cadmia, a retired U.S. diplomat disgusted by “this ridiculous xenophobia,” wants to
show her support for international banking. Before the Foreign Bank Fairness Act
becomes law, she seeks to deposit $10,000 at Argon Bank’s Hesperia branch and
$10,000 at Radon Bank’s Hesperia agency. May the banks accept those deposits?
Explain.
(c) Which government has primary responsibility for monitoring the liquidity of Argon
Bank’s Hesperia branch? Explain.
(d) Under the Foreign Bank Fairness Act, the Greenbrier banking commissioner
considers whether a foreign bank’s home country “accords United States banks
competitive opportunities equal to those it accords to banks chartered in that
country.” What concept from this course best describes that standard? Explain.
(e) Krypton Bank applies to the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Reserve
Board to establish a federal branch in Hesperia. The bank has high capital ratios,
strong earnings, and honest, capable management. The Fed stands ready to approve
the application. May the Comptroller approve the application? Explain.
(f) Xenon Bank, chartered and headquartered in the Thulian Republic, has branches
and nonbank subsidiaries in five countries but no U.S. offices. The bank has high
capital ratios, strong earnings, and honest, capable management.
Thulia, a small island nation, seeks to become an international financial center. It
has an honest, competent government with a strong free-market orientation. The
current finance minister has overseen a thorough revision of bank soundness,
consumer protection, and anti-money-laundering rules, all aimed at achieving key
policy objectives without imposing burdensome compliance costs. The finance
ministry requires banks to meet all Basel capital standards. It carefully examines
their Thulian operations. In supervising their overseas activities, it often relies on
banks’ outside auditors (all of which are Big Four accounting firms) and on hostcountry
bank regulators. It requires banks to file detailed financial reports quarterly.
Xenon Bank applies to the Greenbrier banking commissioner and the Federal
Reserve Board to establish a state branch in Hesperia. The commissioner approves
the application, having found that Thulia accords U.S. banks competitive
PAGE 7 OF 10
opportunities equal to those it accords to its own banks. May the Fed also approve
the branch? Explain.
ESSAY 2 (42 minutes)
Chromium Corporation is a toy dealer headquartered in the State of Allegheny. It buys
toys from manufacturers and sells them to retailers. Chromium’s competitors may have
marketing research departments, but Chromium has Selenia, its CEO. According to a
leading trade publication, Selenia has “an unerring sense of style” and “an uncanny ability
to anticipate what kids will want next.” She uses these skills to assure Chromium ample
inventories of “gotta get” toys before they become scarce. She is also a gifted toy designer.
Chromium earns its highest profit margins on her creations.
“Battroborg and Cyberella will be hot this year,” Selenia tells her staff. “So will Matilda
and Horrid Henry. We’ve stocked up on them already. But I’ve just thought up a new
action figure: Batilda. We’ll need to move fast to have her in stock by October. Let’s send
the order to Osmium. It’s not our cleverest contractor, but it’s prompt.” Osmium Ltd. is a
manufacturer based in the Despotate of Boronia, a politically stable but notoriously corrupt
country. It conducts no business activities and has no assets in the United States.
Selenia sends Osmium her specifications and negotiates a contract (#37-4396) to purchase
20,000 Batildas:
Twenty thousand (20,000) posable plastic figurines manufactured in accordance
with the drawings in Contract No. 37-4396.
Under the contract, Allegheny law governs the transaction and Allegheny courts have
jurisdiction over any dispute between the parties.
At Chromium’s request, Iridium National Bank, headquartered in Allegheny, issues an
irrevocable letter of credit for the benefit of Osmium. To obtain payment under the letter,
Osmium must present three copies of the following documents:
- Signed commercial invoice, indicating contract number and letter of credit
number, for posable plastic figurines manufactured in accordance with the
drawings in Contract No. 37-4396
- Air bill of lading, marked “freight prepaid”
PAGE 8 OF 10
- Packing list showing for each package the number and net weight of the goods
- Certificate of insurance
One sunny morning, Chromium receives by air freight four large boxes, each triple-lined
with thick plastic. Selenia soon learns why. The boxes contain not the desired Batildas but
20,000 packages of freeze-dried bat parts (“bat” as in “flying mammal”). Selenia calls
Iridium Bank and tells Rutherford, a vice president, to “stop payment” to Osmium.
Rutherford explains that one cannot stop payment on a letter of credit but can seek a court
order against payment.
One week later, the bank receives Osmium’s demand for payment accompanied by copies
of the commercial invoice, air bill of lading, packing list, and certificate of insurance. The
commercial invoice describes the goods as follows:
Twenty throusand (20000.00) pose able plastic figurins manufac turd in acordance
with he dRawings in Contract Numbre #37-43-96.
Chromium gives timely notice of all appropriate objections, then sues the bank and
Osmium in an Allegheny court, seeking an injunction against payment to Osmium.
Assume that Allegheny law governs the letter of credit. The state has no statute regarding
letters of credit and no judicial decisions in point. The court may thus decide the case in
light of reason and experience, taking into account good public policy and the law of other
jurisdictions.
(a) Under the laws we have studied in this course, how should the court decide the
case? Explain.
(b) Would you answer any differently under the following scenario? Upon learning of
the bat-part fiasco, Rutherford asks his contact at the bank’s Boronian
correspondent bank how such a thing could have happened. The contact replies that
Osmium’s owner, terminally ill, has told friends that he resents “the great Selenia
and her high-handed ways” and wants to “give her a memorable comeuppance.” As
always, explain your answer.
(c) Selenia and Rutherford discuss the terms of a letter of credit Chromium will provide
to an overseas supplier unrelated to Osmium. Stung by her experience with
Osmium, Selenia wants the letter to specify that the bank will pay the supplier only
PAGE 9 OF 10
if the goods meet certain objective tests—tests that most intelligent adults could
perform in five minutes. May the bank issue such a letter? Explain.
ESSAY 3 (32 minutes)
Cobalt National Bank, headquartered in the State of Niagara, has a branch in the Republic
of Thoria. The branch offers accounts denominated in U.S. dollars and accounts
denominated in the Thorian currency, the zinco.
Lawrence and Rhoda both have dollar-denominated accounts at the branch. Lawrence, a
history professor, has $50,000 on deposit. Rhoda, a physician serving as Thoria’s minister
for public health, has $80,000 on deposit. The written agreements governing these
accounts permit unlimited withdrawals upon demand. They say nothing about where the
deposits can or cannot be withdrawn. The two depositors are unrelated and their accounts
are completely separate.
A global recession batters Thoria’s export-dependent economy. Exports fall much more
sharply than imports, creating a trade deficit that depletes the country’s foreign currency
reserves. The Thorian government takes various steps to conserve the country’s remaining
foreign currency reserves and defend the value of the zinco. These steps include
prohibiting Thorian banks and Thorian branches of foreign banks from allowing
withdrawals in foreign currency. But the zinco continues to lose value.
(a) As economic distress deepens in Thoria, a radical government takes power.
Lawrence leaves to become a visiting professor at the University of Niagara. He
goes to a Niagara branch of Cobalt Bank and seeks to withdraw $10,000 from his
account. The bank rebuffs him, citing Thoria’s moratorium on withdrawals.
Lawrence sues the bank in a Niagara court, seeking return of his $50,000. Under the
laws we have studied in this course, how should the court decide the case? Explain.
(b) The Thorian government places Rhoda under house arrest, branding her a “class
enemy and foreign stooge.” She escapes from Thoria and obtains political asylum in
the United States. The Thorian government serves Cobalt Bank’s Thorian branch
with an order confiscating her account and requiring the branch to pay the balance
to the government. The branch complies.
PAGE 10 OF 10
Rhoda goes to the Niagara main office of Cobalt Bank and seeks to withdraw
money from her account (“something, anything, even zincos”). A bank officer
replies that the bank paid the entire balance to the Thorian government; nothing
remains for her to withdraw. Rhoda sues the bank in a Niagara court, seeking return
of her $80,000. Under the laws we have studied in this course, how should the court
decide the case?
Niagara has no statutes or judicial decisions in point. The Niagara courts may thus decide
both cases in light of reason and experience, taking into account good public policy and the
law of other jurisdictions.
ESSAY 4 (18 minutes)
Neptune National Bank, headquartered in California, has $10 billion in total assets, $9
billion in total liabilities, and $1 billion in equity. All of the equity counts as regulatory
capital, and the bank meets all capital standards. The bank has no branch or other office
outside the United States.
(a) To better serve its customers, the bank wants to establish a branch in the Republic
of Palladia. What step(s) must the bank take to satisfy U.S. regulatory requirements
for establishing a branch? Explain.
The bank establishes the branch in Palladia.
(b) The bank’s U.S. main office has outstanding $40 million in unsecured loans to
Vanadium Corporation and no other extensions of credit to Vanadium. How large
an unsecured loan may the bank’s Palladian branch make to Vanadium? Explain.
END OF EXAMINATION
Thank you for your participation in this course
